Every time a Marvel Cinematic Universe movie comes out, the score is subject to great debate. Many have tried but few have succeeded in delivering a universally acclaimed score for such a movie. Things seem to have settled now, because Brian Tyler is owning the franchise. But when he doesn’t write the music, problems arise…
“Captain America: The Winter Soldier” is one of the most polarizing scores of 2014. For many, it was an incomprehensible mess. I haven’t listened to it when it came out and all these opinions where possibly altering my experience with it. I had enjoyed Alan Silvestri’s theme for the first movie, and I loved most of Henry Jackman’s work, so the premises were there for an enjoyable score.
The first four cues passed without registering. Ok, this happens…but then “Fury” came. I hoped it was just a glitch. Then “The winter soldier” started…I get weird themes. I understand the need for them and I enjoy them when the composer really knows how to deliver them. But there’s good weird, plain weird and bad weird. ”The winder soldier” falls into the last category. This cue sounded like the Joker theme from “The dark knight” deconstructed and put back together in a way that would make Frankenstein’s monster look cute. Unfortunately, with a theme like this, I had a hard time believing the score and enjoying its moment of brilliance.
And there are such moments in “The winter soldier”. For example “Fallen” is an interesting atmospheric cue. When Henry Jackman doesn’t try to experiment with weird stuff, the cues are enjoyable. “Taking a stand” is a ray of light that I would have liked to have seen expanded upon. My biggest problem with this score was that there are no themes to take away. The “Hydra” experiment fails as well, there’s nothing but silence in this cue.
“Captain America: The winter soldier” isn’t a bad score. It is just a sort of failed experiment. When this score is over, all I’m left with is the weirdness and a slight discomfort provided by some of the tracks…Most of the time, this score sounded as if I tried to catch a radio station on the dial for an hour and only managed to get a clean sound for about ten scattered minutes…
Cue rating: 60 / 100
Total minutes of excellence: 7 / 66
Album excellence: 11%
Taking a stand
End of the line